Press "Enter" to skip to content

BHAB, BHSA, and CPP Promise

Last updated on September 17, 2026

Re: Fully Realizing the Promise of BHSA Community Planning and Local Behavioral Health Advisory Board Oversight

Dear Behavioral Health Services Leadership:

California’s transition from the Mental Health Services Act to the Behavioral Health Services Act provides counties with an extraordinary opportunity to reconsider not simply what behavioral health services we fund, but how we plan, evaluate, improve, and make decisions about them with the communities we serve.

I believe we are at risk of missing an important part of that opportunity.

Counties have become increasingly effective at conducting community outreach. We hold listening sessions, make presentations, conduct surveys and focus groups, attend existing community meetings, gather comments, and provide public hearings. San Diego County’s recent BHSA planning process significantly expanded these activities and deserves recognition for doing so.

But outreach and consultation are not necessarily the same thing as meaningful participation in planning.

The BHSA sets a substantially higher expectation. Welfare and Institutions Code §5963.03 requires counties to demonstrate a partnership with constituents and stakeholders throughout the planning process, including meaningful involvement in behavioral health policy, program planning and implementation, monitoring, workforce, quality improvement, health equity, evaluation, and budget allocations. DHCS similarly emphasizes that stakeholders must receive sufficient information and data to participate meaningfully.

That is a fundamentally different model from periodically asking people what they think.

A person cannot meaningfully evaluate a proposed program without understanding the need it addresses, the population being served, existing alternatives, utilization and outcome data, cost, funding restrictions, disparities, and previous performance. Nor can stakeholders meaningfully contribute to a billion-dollar behavioral health system if most of their participation consists of hearing condensed presentations followed by several minutes of questions or responding to predetermined survey questions.

Meaningful engagement requires investment in stakeholder capacity.

BHSA gives counties resources to make that possible. Counties may allocate up to 5 percent of annual Behavioral Health Services Fund revenue for planning costs. Five percent should not be treated as a spending target; counties should not spend money simply because it is available. But neither should such an important resource remain underutilized while counties struggle to develop informed, representative, sustained community participation.

DHCS specifically recognizes planning expenditures for stakeholder stipends, wages and contracts; translation and interpretation; accessibility; transportation; childcare and eldercare; technology; virtual-engagement infrastructure; and training and technical assistance—including training necessary to understand fiscal policy.

In San Diego County, the scale of the opportunity is particularly striking. Our current materials identify more than $12 million in first-year BHSA planning expenditures, yet the BHAB itself has historically had little visibility into how the planning strategy and budget were developed or how their effectiveness should be measured.

This brings me to the second opportunity: fully enabling our local Behavioral Health Advisory Boards and Commissions to perform the role California law assigns to them.

Welfare and Institutions Code §5604.2 does not describe a board whose principal function is to receive presentations from its behavioral health department. Among other responsibilities, the local board must review and evaluate community behavioral health needs, services, facilities, and special problems; review certain county agreements; advise both the governing body and behavioral health director; review performance outcome data; submit its own annual report on system needs and performance; and, critically, “review and approve the procedures used to ensure citizen and professional involvement at all stages of the planning process.”

The California Association of Local Behavioral Health Boards and Commissions likewise treats these as active oversight responsibilities and provides boards with training, Data Notebook tools, site-visit procedures, workgroup models, recruitment guidance, and other resources intended to make local boards effective rather than ceremonial.

California law goes even further. WIC §5604.3 encourages governing bodies to provide local behavioral health boards with a budget, using BHSA planning and administrative revenues, sufficient to facilitate their statutory purposes, duties, and responsibilities.

I believe counties should now use these authorities deliberately. I respectfully recommend that BHS leadership, Behavioral Health Advisory Boards, and Boards of Supervisors collaboratively establish the following:

  1. A written CPP governance and engagement plan. Before major Integrated Plan development begins, the county should document how stakeholders will be identified, educated, compensated where appropriate, provided data, engaged in deliberation, involved at decision points, and informed about what happened to their recommendations. The BHAB should formally review and approve the procedures as required by WIC §5604.2—not merely receive a retrospective report describing engagement activities after they occurred.
  2. A standing community planning infrastructure. Counties should consider a Community Planning Team, steering committee, or network of subject-matter workgroups that can do the deeper work a volunteer BHAB cannot reasonably accomplish during a few hours of monthly meetings. Other counties have developed geographic, cultural, consumer, peer, and planning bodies to supplement their formal advisory boards. The objective should be year-round institutional knowledge rather than rebuilding a stakeholder audience every three years.
  3. A defined and transparent planning budget. Stakeholders and the BHAB should understand what the county proposes to spend on planning, what activities those expenditures support, what portion supports meaningful community participation, and what outcomes are expected. The question should not be, “Did we spend 5 percent?” but rather, “Did we adequately resource the process necessary to produce informed participation and a better behavioral health system?”
  4. Independent capacity for the BHAB itself. Each governing body should determine what staffing, training, analytical assistance, site visits, conference participation, technology, and other resources its BHAB requires to perform its statutory duties and establish an appropriate BHAB operating budget. Administrative support from BHS is valuable, but the advisory board must retain its own judgment, priorities, findings, and voice.
  5. An annual BHAB oversight work plan tied directly to WIC §5604.2. The board should systematically schedule reviews of community needs, facilities, programs, agreements and procurements, outcomes, workforce, equity, access, major system changes, and CPP performance rather than depending primarily on subjects selected for presentation by staff. Its annual report to the Board of Supervisors should reflect the BHAB’s independent findings and recommendations, even when staff assists with data and drafting.
  6. A formal recommendations-and-response system. BHAB recommendations should be specific, voted upon when appropriate, transmitted to BHS and the governing body, and publicly tracked through disposition. This is particularly important during Integrated Plan review: BHSA requires counties to address substantive BHAB recommendations that are not incorporated into the final plan.
  7. Continuous access to usable performance information. BHAB members and community planning partners should have timely dashboards and briefing materials covering access, utilization, outcomes, disparities, spending, complaints, service gaps, workforce, contracting, and statewide BHSA measures. DHCS now specifically identifies access, homelessness, institutionalization, justice involvement, untreated behavioral health conditions, removal of children from home, and other outcomes as statewide planning goals. A planning body cannot meaningfully exercise oversight if the information necessary to identify problems arrives months or years after decisions are made.

None of this requires diminishing the role or expertise of Behavioral Health Services staff. Quite the opposite.

County behavioral health departments manage extraordinarily complicated systems involving Medi-Cal, substance use treatment, crisis response, housing, hospitals, law enforcement, schools, community organizations, providers, workforce shortages, rapidly changing state requirements, and billions of dollars in public investment. That complexity is precisely why counties should take advantage of the enormous reservoir of expertise outside their departments.

People receiving services know things administrators cannot know. Family members see transitions and gaps that individual programs cannot see. Providers understand operational barriers. Peers understand why people disengage. Community organizations understand cultural and geographic barriers. Public-safety and justice partners see another portion of the system. Researchers and data experts can identify patterns. Fiscal, procurement, workforce, housing, education, health, and civil-rights stakeholders each bring knowledge that can improve county decisions.

The purpose of community planning should be to organize that collective intelligence and put it to work.

San Diego has already taken steps in this direction. The County expanded BHSA outreach, established a temporary BHSA Community Planning ad hoc subcommittee, created additional public engagement mechanisms, and more recently has brought Integrated Plan recommendations and procurement matters before the BHAB. These are meaningful improvements.

The opportunity now is to institutionalize the model.

A temporary committee should become lasting planning capacity. Engagement counts should evolve into measures of engagement quality and influence. Presentations should lead to informed deliberation. Public comment should complement—not substitute for—collaboration. Planning funds should build lasting stakeholder capability. And BHABs should be equipped to provide their Boards of Supervisors with something neither the behavioral health department nor its contractors can provide: an informed, community-based, appropriately independent assessment of how well the behavioral health system is serving the people for whom it exists.

That is not adversarial oversight. It is good governance.

BHSA has given California counties an opportunity to build something much more consequential than a better three-year plan. We can build an informed civic infrastructure around behavioral health—one in which consumers, families, providers, peers, community organizations, professionals, and public agencies continuously learn from one another and participate in improving the system.

We already have much of the statutory authority. We have access to the funding. We have thousands of community members with relevant knowledge and lived experience.

The question is whether we will fully put those resources to work.

I hope San Diego County—and counties throughout California—will use this BHSA transition to do exactly that.

Mission News Theme by Compete Themes.