Press "Enter" to skip to content

Public Comment: Race, Power, and Accusations

Last updated on November 5, 2026

Below is the full version of a letter being sent today to the BHAB, Behavioral Health Services (BHS), and Board of Supervisors, written as a public comment for today’s BHAB Executive Committee meeting, but it could not be presented due to the meeting being canceled as a result of a lack of quorum.

[Revisions are indicated as a ‘Note:’ and provided for clarification at the bottom of this post.]

2026-09-17

TO: BHAB Executive Committee, CC: Jennifer Bransford-Koons, Interim Director, Behavioral Health Services, Supervisor Jim Anderson, Vice-Chair Monica Montgomery-Steppe, Chair Pro Tem Paloma Aguirre, and Ebony N. Shelton, CAO.

FR: Jerry Hall, Advocate, Je***@*******ab.com

RE: Public Comment, Executive Behavioral Health Advisory Board (BHAB) meeting

Good afternoon.

This BHAB’s bylaws state that “Members should reflect the diversity of the communities served especially matching the racial, sexual, gender and orientation, language, cultural, and any other range of identities that have been historically, disproportionally (sic), disadvantaged, and underrepresented.”  [i]

The Countywide Code of Conduct applies to County boards and commissions such as the BHAB and expressly calls for “courteous, respectful, and equitable treatment” and an environment free of “discrimination, intimidation, or harassment.” [ii]

The BHAB Nominating Committee (NC), consists of five BHAB Members appointed by the BHAB Chair, and confirmed by the full BHAB. The NC had met previously and met again yesterday, September 16, 2026, to consider its recommended slate of nominations for the 2026-27 Executive Board. [iii]


What follows is my understanding of what occurred at this NC meeting, based on a conversation with a participating member. I welcome correction of any factual inaccuracies.


The NC discussed a potential slate that included four white-appearing men and one woman, the current BHAB Chair, who is on maternity leave. {Statement removed, see 10/1 Revisions below}.

The Member suggested a slate that removed the current Chair and, in her place, elevated the BHAB Acting Chair, who is a Black woman and also serves on the NC.

The BHAB Acting Chair posed a concern and accidentally mischaracterized the recommended slate as including four white men and herself. She asked whether that composition reflected the County’s racial diversity.

A third NC Member, one of the four men proposed on the slate, clarified that he did not identify as white. The BHAB Acting Chair immediately acknowledged the member and apologized for her mistake.

That should have ended that part of the discussion. It apparently did not.

Instead, according to the account I received, the NC Member this document addresses expressed multiple concerns. The Member called the BHAB Acting Chair racist because of the mistaken identity characterization, argued that she should not be considered for an officer position, and argued that she should resign as Vice-Chair and/or leave the BHAB altogether.  At this NC meeting, this Member made disparaging remarks about the current BHAB Executive Board being all women, {See 11/5 Revisions below.} and about the women in the meeting while serving as BHS support staff.

The Member proposed that the BHAB Acting Chair should be removed from contention for the BHAB Chair role, and that the committee instead nominate him for the Chair role.

In effect, the Member insisted that the BHAB Acting Chair not be considered for a continuing leadership role and that he alone be nominated for the Chair position.

Not only is the Member’s response disproportionate to the mistake, but his continued disrespectful expressions and apparent personal animosity towards women, and potential conflicts of interest while seeking a leadership role, should lead BHAB members to address this member’s actions. Senior BHS staff ultimately excused junior staff, all women, from the NC meeting so they did not have to endure the continuing abuse. I understand that the Member made other disparaging comments, directed insulting remarks toward BHS staff, and repeatedly interrupted members and staff attempting to intervene.

Not only are this member’s misogynistic statements and aggressive behavior concerning, but the part I find most disturbing is that a Black woman leader raised a legitimate concern about racial representation and an obvious inequity, immediately corrected and apologized for a mistaken assumption, and the conversation reportedly turned into an attack on her character and credentials in an effort to remove her from leadership.

Whatever terminology one chooses to describe these interactions and that Member’s reaction, we should recognize the dynamic. When someone raises uncomfortable questions about race and representation, particularly a Black woman in a predominantly white institution, the response cannot be to silence, humiliate, or punish them after raising the concern.

A discussion about diversity became a discussion about whether the Black woman who raised it deserved to remain at the table. That should trouble every member of this Board, the Board of Supervisors, and the community at large!

If this account is substantially accurate, this is no longer simply a disagreement between BHAB Board Members. It is a governance issue. Leadership carries a higher obligation—not a license to intimidate people with whom one disagrees. And certainly not to disparage others because of their identity, gender, race, or other immutable characteristics.

This is a BHAB governance question. I therefore urge the BHAB Executive Board, in consultation with the Interim BHS Director, to review what occurred, speak directly with everyone who participated, and determine whether this conduct is compatible with the offending Member’s continued service on BHAB. If the facts are confirmed, I believe the District 2 Supervisor’s Office should be formally asked to remove this Seat 6 Member from service immediately.

BHAB members voluntarily lend their experience and expertise to act as the eyes and ears for the Board of Supervisors that appoints them, over a behavioral health system with an approximately $1.4 billion annual budget, and an explicit mandate and responsibility to serve San Diego County’s diverse communities equitably and fairly.

People must be able to raise concerns about race, disparities, representation, and institutional performance without fearing personal retaliation.

We cannot claim to value diversity while attacking people for talking about it. San Diego County has declared ‘Racism A Public Health Crisis’ [iv]. This incident appears to be a manifestation of that crisis, one that can be immediately remedied.  

We cannot provide meaningful oversight of a behavioral health system if members or staff are intimidated for challenging the status quo.

We must do better.

Thank you.


[i] County of San Diego Behavioral Health Advisory Board Bylaws (BHAB). 2021.  Article II, Section B.2. and B.3.:

“2. Members should have experience and knowledge of the behavioral health system and should reflect the diversity and demographics of the county as a whole, and the diversity of the client population, to the extent feasible.

3. The Advisory Board may recommend persons for appointment. The Advisory Board is committed to diversity, equity, and inclusion, and appointed Members should reflect the diversity of the communities served especially matching the racial, sexual, gender and orientation, language, cultural, and any other range of identities that have been historically, disproportionally, disadvantaged, and underrepresented.”

[ii] San Diego County Boards and Commissions Code of Conduct. 2022. https://www.sandiegocounty.gov/content/sdc/cob/sdcountybccs/bcc_conduct_code.html?utm_source=chatgpt.com includes in part:
“By our conduct, we create an environment in which we adhere to and pledge to uphold the following values:

  • We acknowledge that the principal function of County of San Diego boards, commissions, committees and planning and sponsor groups (or representatives) is public service, and we therefore commit to serving the public interest and promoting the greatest public good.
  • We recognize that our actions impact the community’s trust in the County and government as a whole and commit to act with honesty and integrity.
  • We commit to vigilance in avoiding bias or conflict of interest whether they be real or perceived, acknowledging that even the perception of such corrodes public trust.
  • We commit to fairness, impartiality, active listening, and consideration of all points of view by setting aside our personal agendas, affiliations, and biases.  We make informed decisions after carefully weighing relevant data and assessing the merits and possible impacts.  
  • We recognize that diversity is a strength and commit to promoting an inclusive and welcoming culture at public meetings and with each other to foster participation and representation across all our varied communities. 
  • We practice civility by fostering a professional environment of courteous, respectful, and equitable treatment of our fellow members, elected officials, County staff and the residents we serve, through our words and actions whether we agree or disagree.
  • We are committed to fostering an environment free from violence, discrimination, intimidation, or harassment of any kind”

[iii] The BHAB Nominating Committee (NC) presents their slate and/or individual candidates at the October 1, 2026 full BHAB meeting, when eligible and willing individuals may also be nominated from the floor. Members vote on the NC slate and/or individual nominations at the November 5, 2026 meeting, and the new Executive Board commences December 1, 2026.  

[iv] San Diego County Supervisors Declare Racism A Public Health Crisis. January 12, 2021. https://www.kpbs.org/news/politics/2021/01/12/supervisors-declare-racism-public-health-crisis

Notes, Revisions, and Clarifications

[9/17 My original content:  “One Member, the individual of concern referred to in this document, said the current Chair was unfit for the role next year because of her pregnancy.”

[9/17/2026 2:04 p.m. Note: Irony aside, the NC Member who was mischaracterized as ‘white’ is the individual who made the original comment about the BHAB Chair’s pregnancy and potential unsuitability for leadership.]

[10/1/2026 6:53 p.m. Note: The BHAB Member on the Nominating Committee stated in the General BHAB meeting today, that he did not state that the Chair was unfit for duty because of her maternity leave, he said he simply asked if she would want to accept the nomination, given her recent delivery. (in fact, she did accept the First Vice-Chair nomination). He said he acted out of concern, not questioning her viability as the Chair.

This was my misunderstanding of what I learned occurred during the meeting, and I removed the statement from this post because it is believed to be false.]

[11/5/2026 [Note: this statement was also removed in paragraph 8: ‘about the Chair being unfit for service due to her maternity leave,’ due to the reasoning described above, and my missing it on 10/1/2026.]

Mission News Theme by Compete Themes.